A Catholic Teen’s POV: Women Ordination

Let’s get some facts out here before I start: I’m a Catholic, and I’m a woman. Now let’s continue on.

I didn’t know this recently, but a woman in my diocese had excommunicated herself in 2008 when she became “ordained.” I read about several articles on the topic here. I was surprised to hear about our emeritus bishop’s reaction and the four priests who had supposedly supported her.

Anyways, I am in no way educated theologically enough to give opinions on that. But, I do have humble opinions on this matter and topic.

I’ll admit, I’m a former altar server, accompanist, and am involved with other activities at my parish. And most of the time, 75% of the volunteers are women. Which brings me to a thought? How are women being oppressed in the Catholic Church if they do so many ministries? The matter of women ordination seems more like an issue of pride to me.

So, here’s my take on it: I don’t think women should be ordained in the Roman Catholic Church. Honestly, it’ll never happen. But, I should say I’m not bothered by that at all.

In my everyday life, I hear of numerous people bringing up the fact that women still are not considered equality in today’s society, yet. I agree, the fact that women haven’t fully obtained equality is true. I dare to say I’m not a feminist, but I do believe in women equality.

But, becoming ordained is not something to be grasped by earthly hands with prideful fingers. I’ve seen stories where it seems as the problem lies in a person’s pride more than the actual idea of “equality for both men and women.” Many argue saying women are prohibited from fully serving the Church, but I disagree.

There’s various ways that I see women fulfill their want of serving their Church without the need of thinking they should be ordained. Women are now given many roles that were not given to us before, but it seems greedy that many are trying to take the sacred role of priesthood reserved for men. Men and women are both important in the ministries of the Church, although the roles are different, they are equal.

The majority of volunteers are women, and I’ve witnessed the importance of women in a parish. While I understand that some women state they want to do more by becoming ordained, I wonder why those women don’t accept that the priesthood was instituted by Christ for males.

I’m not bothered by this, or angered by this at all. I accept the roles I’ve been given, and more importantly, I see no particular reason as to why certain women have such a want to become ordained. I think there are other ministries that are equal, and they’d be able to serve the Church in those ways as well.

“Female altar servers might want to become priests,” this is something I’ve heard. But, maybe you’ve seen my blog post on my experience as an altar server, I wanted to reiterate that altar serving did not inspire any want to become a priest from me or other females that I knew. But, it is possible that is where certain women put their basis of their argument.

In conclusion, I see more pride in this issue than a problem about equality. If you have any other thoughts, please let me know, I’d be delighted to know your thoughts and response. Although I didn’t provide any theological aspects about it, there’s a great link talking about it found on catholic.com: http://www.catholic.com/tracts/women-and-the-priesthood 


4 thoughts on “A Catholic Teen’s POV: Women Ordination

  1. When I hear comments that the Catholic Church does not value women simply because we do not have women priests, I think first of Mary. The greatest role model, aside from Christ, that we have in our faith is His mother Mary. Many other faiths seem to place Mary on the back shelf so to speak and forget her words that “all generations shall call me blessed.” It seems to me that aside from all the wonderful opportunities women do have to serve in our Church as you mentioned in your post, if the Catholic Church was truly trying to oppress women, we certainly wouldn’t start by honoring a woman and looking to her to show us example of how to live a good Christian life!

    Great post! God Bless!


  2. As a seminarian discerning priesthood, I commend you on this post and thank you for standing up for the Church and for Christ. I think another that people don’t realize is how many of the Doctors of the Church are women, who had a big influence on the Church: St. Teresa of Avila, St. Catherine of Sienna, St. Therese of Lisieux. You are so right on many levels. Now of course many people will argue the same thing for all male altar servers as it does have a good influence on helping young men consider priesthood. Thanks for posting and defending your Catholic Faith.

    Liked by 1 person

    • First off, I’d like to thank you for responding to God’s call! Thank you, I only felt it was right to voice that there were many young women who fully stood up for the Christ and the Church’s stances. That is very true, thank you for reminding me! The female saints, especially the Doctors of the Church, definitely remind us that the Church does indeed recognize women for their equal roles. Those female saints never argued to be ordained, so I think it would be wise for women to try and imitate the holiness in the lives of all the saints instead. I do think that altar serving does help young men consider the priesthood. And quite sadly, I’ve seen male friends that did not want to serve simply because they thought it wasn’t an ideal male activity. Thank you for your input, I’m glad to be able to defend our Catholic faith. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s